The Straw Bag Guide: When Craftsmanship Costs $3,000 (And When It Doesn't)
Watch the Video | Shop my Picks
Summer's here, and with it comes the annual question: are luxury straw bags a worthwhile entrypoint into the realm of rarified accessories, or are we paying for logos wrapped in raffia? The journey toward an anwer take us from $60 Mango pieces to $5,300 Saint Laurent totes, and I think this legwork will bring more joy to your bag than scrolling and swooning.
Reading the Weave: Your First Quality Check
The most telling detail isn't in the description or brand — it's the tightness and consistency of the weave. Quality straw bags feature dense, even weaving without gaps that will snag on jewelry or catch on rough surfaces. Loose weaves might look artisanal, but they're structurally weak and likely to age poorly.
When examining any straw bag, run your fingers along the surface. The best pieces feel substantial and uniform, whether you're holding a $118 J.Crew Como tote or an Hermès Picnic Kelly. This tactile test reveals more about longevity than any logo ever could.
The Trim Truth: Where Quality Really Shows
Here's where luxury brands often justify their prices — and where many fall short. The leather trim work on straw bags requires genuine skill to execute well. The base material needs to be thin enough to create clean lines, and the stitching must be precise.
Compare Jacquemus charging $340 for visibly uneven stitches on their Soli basket to J.Crew's clean trim execution at less than half the price. J.Crew understood that successful trim requires a thinner straw base—a detail that speaks to thoughtful construction rather than rushed production.
Mango's plastic-looking patches are an instant fail at any price point. If the trim looks synthetic or poorly finished, it will only deteriorate from there.
The Logo Question: When Branding Backfires
Saint Laurent, Gucci, and Dolce&Gabbana
Some of the most expensive straw bags are covered in logos, but this approach fundamentally misunderstands what makes straw bags appealing. The charm lies in their natural, effortless quality — something that prominent branding actively undermines. Unless done with self-aware humor, of course.
Sézane's Justine basket exemplifies the ideal approach: hand-woven Madagascan raffia with impeccable leather detailing and only a small embossed logo. At $245-390, it delivers luxury refinement without throwing a branding tantrum for attention.
For true luxury without the drastic markup, Helen Kaminski offers the same level of craftsmanship as Loewe at half the price. Their Lipari Tote ($375) features the tight weaving and quality leather details that justify premium pricing.